Regardless of the type of diapers you use, diaper rash is inevitable, but considerably less likely to occur with cloth diapers. This baby skin condition is a sensitive subject, and it is important to be well informed and have on hand the best diaper rash ointment/creams in case your baby requires treatment.
That said, we’ve spent well over 60 hours of research speaking to some of the most esteemed pediatricians and parents about their experience with diaper rash and which ointment is the magical healer.
Although we received several different answers, our goal was to find a diaper rash ointment that would help with several different types of nappy rashes, and the Triple Paste ointment was a clear winner for several reasons.
Our Pick – Triple Paste
Triple paste comes highly recommended by some of the most leading pediatricians and dermatologists, and is designed to work quickly to relive irritated skin.
It offers a long time barrier and helps prevent diaper rash relapse owing to its rich, tried and tested formulation of ingredients.
One of the noteworthy features that make this diaper rash ointment distinct from the competition is that the company offers a 100% money back guarantee if you’re not fully satisfied with the product.
Runner Up – Boudreaux’s Butt Paste
If you’d like to know why Boudreaux’s Butt Paste takes our runner up position for best diaper rash ointment, and you don’t like reading, over 800 positive reviews on Amazon alone should give you a hint.
Long story short, a pharmacist teamed up with an esteemed pediatrician to create this product in the early 1970, so yes this miracle treatment for nappy rash has been working wonders for over 4 decades.
Up until 1994, this product was sold exclusively through a pharmacy in Covington L.A. and today is not just limited to babies and diaper rash, but is used by bikers, hikers, joggers and world class athletes for its superb protection against wetness.
Upgrade Pick – Burts Bees Baby Bee
Formulated with 40% zinc oxide and sweet almond oil for superior protection, the Burts Bees Baby Bee diaper rash ointment is a proven treatment solution for several different types of nappy rashes.
The ointment when applied properly creates a great layer that shields your baby from wetness that can irritate your baby’s skin.
One of the noteworthy features of this diaper ointment is that it not only treats diaper rash, but prevents it too. It is pediatrician tested and contains no petrolatum, phthalates, parabens or SLS, making it effective, safe and natural to use.
Budget Pick – Weleda Calendula
Made entirely of natural ingredients, this diaper rash ointment is formulated to protect as well as sooth, and relieves your baby’s skin of redness and inflammation. Consumers like this product for several reasons, most notably pleasant smell, petroleum-free and extremely effective.
The main ingredient – organic calendula flower is sourced from is the company’s Biodynamic® garden in Germany, making this a trusted remedy for diaper rash.
Also Great – Sudocrem
A moms favorite for over 80 years, Sudocrem is regarded as a multi-faceted solution in that it can heal several issues including cut, grazes, minor burns, eczema, acne and diaper rash.
Developed way back in 1931 by Thomas Smith – a professor of pharmacy, this diaper rash ointment is still manufactured in Dublin, but is distributed across 40 countries worldwide and has sold an astounding half a million tubs in South Africa alone.
If you can’t get your hands on other diaper rash solutions, Sudocrem is definitely worth checking out.
Table of Contents:
- Why you should trust me
- Should you get this
- How I picked
- How I tested
- My Pick
- Flaws but not Deal breaker
- The Competition
- Final Thoughts
Why you should trust me
I interviewed several leading pediatricians and parents to get a drift of what diaper ointments work and ones that aren’t worth the efforts before concurring on our top pick.
They filled me in on causes and types of diaper rash, and how the best diaper rash creams work to heal and prevent further occurrences.
Before I started working on this guide, I thought that any soothing cream could serve as diaper rash ointment as well, but I was not on the right track. And while I did settle initially for the first diaper rash ointment off the shelves, it really made the situation worse than when it fist was.
Should you get this?
Whether you’re a parent or not, diaper rash ointment can heal several ailments including acne so it is wise to make it part of your first aid arsenal. Adding to this, it is extremely affordable so there’s no reason not to have it around.
In fact, there are several moms that keep the diaper rash samples they receive at stores and have used it successfully for other reasons.
After reading some of the other uses of diaper rash cream, you will not only feel comfortable exploring the other uses of this ointment, but would mind sharing it with friends in a stocking stuffer or even giving them out next Halloween.
Most notably, diaper rash cream such as our top pick works miraculously on razor burn especially in the bikini area and even ingrown hair. Believe it or not, it also works like a charm on chapped lips, wrinkles and to eliminate puffiness under the eyes.
Some individuals I spoke to claimed that diaper rash ointments can reduce certain types of acne, and apart from providing relief for psoriasis, eczema and other skin rashes, it serves as a superior barrier against all kinds of cuts and scrapes.
And worth mentioning is the fact that diaper rash creams can also prevent underarm sweat and helps to moisturize and reduce scaly skin build-up, and surprisingly prevents foot sweat and odor.
How I Picked
First things first, when choosing the right diaper rash cream, you will be spoilt for choice considering the myriad options available.
But letting you know how I first picked will help you make the right choice and not be overwhelmed at the shelves. Fact is that diaper rash is inevitable despite your best care, but on a brighter note it is generally easily treatable with diaper rash creams.
Take note that although the ointments I’ve mentioned works for diaper rash as well as yeast infection, you will probably need a specific anti-fungal ointment to cure the latter if a diaper rash solution doesn’t prove helpful.
Even the most natural diaper rash creams are infused with some level of zinc oxide, which is basically there to make the cream work. I chose diaper rash creams that served as a barrier between your baby’s skin and the hostile diaper rash environment.
Whether you buy diaper rash cream or diapers, it must be safe for your baby. That said, I selected diaper rash creams based on how effective they were instead of price.
All the creams I’ve reviewed in this guide are deemed safe by leading medical professionals and have received positive reviews for the most part. Most diaper rash creams emit some level of fragrance for obvious reasons, but this aspect does not affect the effectiveness of the ointment or prove harmful to your baby’s skin.
Next, I looked at some of the best top diaper rash treatment lists, and from there compared roughly 100 different products.
Although these weren’t clear as to why they recommended these diaper rash solutions, I did gauge some crucial information, but did not consider them further.
My experts suggested that we avoid remedies laden with chemicals so this is exactly what I did and concurred on 5 best natural (for the most part) diaper rash creams.
How I tested
Testing the best diaper rash ointments required the help of a mix of pediatricians and parents so that I get the unbiased feedback from the best of both worlds.
Three of those testers were given the best out of the 5 diapers rash ointments to take home and apply it on their baby and had medical professionals apply them on patients as they deemed fit.
All of the diaper rash ointments I tested even the ones that claimed they had no fragrance did have some sort of pleasant odor and as mentioned earlier, this is for obvious reasons.
Adding to this, some fragrances were more potent than others, but regardless all ointments were safe to use. The testers often disagreed over what products were most effective, and this was expected given not all baby’s skins are created equal.
But what’s most important is that the diaper rash creams do offer great relief for diaper rash and even other skin ailment.
Lastly and worth mentioning is the fact that I wanted all our chosen diaper rash ointments to be available both online and offline and across the country, which means Amazon for the most part is where you can also read tons of reviews relevant to the respective product.
Our Pick for The Best Diaper Rash Ointment – Triple Paste
Brought to you by Summer Labs – an innovative yet small pharmaceutical company that is geared to discovering new skin treatments, Triple Paste is one the best diaper rash ointments available in the market, and with more than 500 celebrated reviews on Amazon alone, I wholeheartedly agree.
Apart from nappy rash, the company’s main goal is to address the needs of patients that also suffer from eczema, psoriasis, acne and other ailments that’s affect the nails and scalp.
Apart from diaper rash reviews, Triple Paste comes highly recommended by leading dermatologists and is basically a multi-faceted ointment designed for several different skin conditions.
One of the aspects that’s sets this diaper rash cream apart for the competition is that it is backed by an unconditional, full money back guarantee. Basically that translates to a complete refund if the product does not work for your baby or you for that matter.
Zinc oxide is the primary ingredient in Triple Paste and is the magical formula that heals minor skin irritations, diaper rash and severe chapped skin among others. The rectal suppositories of zinc oxide are used to treat irritation, burning, itching and other rectal discomfort caused by hemorrhoids or other unpleasant bowl movements.
Although Triple Paste is easily available over the counter without a prescription, it is wise to consult your physician before using it in order to determine if zinc oxide is compatible with your baby’s or your skin.
As early bird advice, Triple Paste should not be used if you are allergic to petroleum jelly, cod liver oil, lanolin, wax, dimethicone, mineral oil or zinc. On a brighter note, these are common ingredients so it’s highly unlikely that you will be allergic to this ointment, but again it’s your baby you’re dealing with, so don’t take any chances.
Adding to this, it is not officially clear if some ingredients in Triple Paste will harm an unborn baby, so speak to your physician if you plan or already are pregnant.
Furthermore, it is also not clear if this diaper rash ointment passes into breast milk and be harmful to a nursing baby and again it is a good idea to seek medical advice on this aspect before using it.
Triple Paste is a combination of several ingredients, most notably white petrolatum, anhydrous lanolin, stearyl alcohol, polysorbate 80, bisabolol, oat kernel extract, cholesterol and zinc oxide.
White Petrolatum – similar to waxy yellow gunk, white petrolatum was often used to coat the surface of oil well drill bits and filtered into a odorless, colorless mass that is impervious to water. Most common known as Vaseline, it is proven to moisturize while keeping baby’s skin dry and is a key ingredient for combating nappy rash.
Anhydrous Lanolin – sheep discharge this rather stinking yellow oil on their wool in an effort to stay waterproofed. This discharge is purified into lanolin, a wax that demonstrates the same melting point temperature as the human body, and is able to thicken the inner skin layer by speeding up the growth of new cells.
Stearyl Alcohol – this type of fatty alcohol today is easily extracted from plants rather than sperm whale oil a few decades ago. When used in diaper rash ointments, it serves as lubricant on the skin’s surface for a soft and smooth appearance.
Polysorbate 80 – a food additive that dates back to the atomic age, this water soluble, yellow liquid has been claimed to cure baldness and flu vaccine among other uses.
Bisabolol – is a type of alcohol that not only works as a skin conditioning agent, but also helps heal dehydrated or damaged skin. It is believed to posses anti-irritant, anti-microbial and anti-inflammatory properties, and can effectively accelerate the skins healing process.
Oat Kernel Extract – this formula contains a very mild anti-fungal protein that is used to specifically treat Candida yeast infections.
Cholesterol – this crucial component of our cell membranes serves as a moisturizer in diaper rash creams and helps boost the effectiveness of other ingredients.
Flaws but not Deal breaker
Although Triple paste is a favorite of thousands of parents worldwide and even highly recommended by leading medical websites such as WebMD, it is not perfect in that it might not work the same for all conditions/individuals/skin types.
Remember, this diaper rash ointment contains a few chemical ingredients so it is best to consult your physician before using it. But most people that have used Triple Paste do not have any adverse side effects and allergic reactions to this drug are rare.
Allergic reactions to this ointment often display symptoms such as trouble breathing, dizziness, rash, itching and swelling. According to one users review, the diaper rash didn’t clear up but also didn’t spread with Triple Paste, but they did claim that the texture of this ointment was smooth and thick.
I’ve mentioned earlier that what diaper rash cream works for you may not render the same results for another, which is why it is highly advisable to try different solutions in order to find the perfect fit.
Runner Up – Boudreaux’s Butt Paste
This American brand of skin cream was first formulated as a remedy for diaper rash, but today is used to treat several skin ailments including cold sores, shingles and psoriasis.
Conceived in the 1970’s by George Boudreaux of Covington, Louisiana along with an intern, this nappy rash cream was first sold at his pharmacy and was later named “Boudreaux’s Butt Paste”. After the pharmacy was sold in 1974, distribution efforts were ramped up and moved from Alabama to New Orleans in 2004.
This product comes highly recommended by leading pediatricians, general physicians and even celebrities such as Oprah Winfrey, who featured it on her own show.
The ingredients in Boudreaux’s Butt Paste include castor oil, mineral oil, petrolatum, Peruvian balsam and 16 percent zinc oxide. The company was then sold to Blairex Industries, but this didn’t change the quality of this diaper rash cream.
Upgrade Pick – Burts Bees Baby Bee
This all natural formula has all the right ingredients to nourish your skin, and with each ingredient being carefully selected, you can expect superior results. Just like most things in nature, your baby’s skin has a life cycle, where new cells are born and live for approximately 28 days, and Burts Bees diaper ointment helps rejuvenate the skin and even serve as a barrier against the outside world.
Formulated with 40 percent zinc oxide and sweet almond oil for superior protection, this nappy rash ointment when applied appropriately creates a barrier that shields your baby’s skin from wetness that can cause irritation. It is specifically designed to heal and prevent diaper rash, and contains no SLS, petrolatum, parabens or phthalates. It is pediatrician tested, making it a safe, effective and natural remedy for diaper rash. It boasts a signature beeswax formula and is easy to rub in and emits a lovely fresh scent.
Budget Pick – Weleda Calendula
An award winner for obvious reasons, there are nappy rash creams that work brilliantly, but Weleda Calendula is a unique product both in its formulation and the way it performs. This is possibly the only diaper rash treatment we’ve come across that doesn’t contain any instances of zinc oxide, making it an organic remedy for diaper rash. The Calendula extract used in its formulation is sourced directly from the company’s own biodynamic gardens in Germany, which in terms of numbers is spread across 50 pristine acres and is the largest of its kind in Europe.
Other natural ingredients in Weleda Calendula diaper cream include petitgrain essential oil (a natural anti-septic), sweet almond oil, fair trade beeswax, sesame oil, camomile extract, cananga oil and hectorite (a natural clay). The combination of these ingredients gives this ointment a rich texture, where most other nappy rash ointments are too runny, greasy and slippery, Weleda Calendula cream is silky smooth yet thick.
Also Great – Sudocrem
Sudocrem has been a mom’s favorite for over 8 decades, and is designed to treat nappy rash and sooth sore skin. This clinically proven formula works in three separate ways – it contains an emollient that sooths sore, it has a water repellant base that serves as a barrier to prevent against any irritants that come in contact with the skin (urine, feces) and lastly it possesses cooling properties to help ease irritation and pain. This gentle yet effective diaper rash cream not only provides relief for discomfort, but also forms a superior barrier over affected and vulnerable areas.
What’s great about Sudocrem is that although it is primarily designed to cure diaper rash ointment, it is also known to provide relief against other skin conditions such as acne and eczema. Other uses for Sudocrem include minor burns, bed sores, cuts, grazes and chilblains. Using this diaper rash remedy is as easy as applying it on your dry baby’s tushy each time you change the diaper. Then gently massage the cream in a circular motion to create a thin, translucent layer on the skin.
Cetaphil Baby Diaper Cream – this product is not only good for your face, but to heal diaper rashes as well. It contains zinc oxide, is dermatologist tested and is mineral oil and colorant free.
A+D original Ointment – great when used at bedtime and with every diaper change this ointment is gentle on your baby’s skin and is pediatrician recommended.
Destin Maximum Strength – designed to help treat and prevent diaper rash, this ointment is known to provide great relief within 12 hours.
Diaper rash ointment is not regular ointment and shouldn’t be treated as such. Although regular ointment such as lotions does contain some skin healing properties, they aren’t up to the task of healing diaper rash. The diaper rash ointments listed above do not just heal diaper rash, but also reduce episodes of future occurrences. Considering that there are several different types of diaper rash prevention creams, each with their own set of ingredients, you may have to try out a couple to determine which one provides the best comfort for your baby. Also remember the most important thing is to seek medical advice first.